Thalo_VRF_Undercharge_Case_Study

Refrigerant Undercharge Detection:

30% Energy Waste Identified & Corrected via Continuous Monitoring

Mitsubishi MXZ-SM36NAMHZ | Colorado Deployment

UNDERCHARGE EFFICIENCY GAIN ANNUAL WASTE CO2 AVOIDED
40% refrigerant deficit ~30% energy intensity reduction ~2,400 kWh ~ $360/yr at $0.15/kWh 1.26 MTCO2/yr (eGRID RMPA)

Temperature-Normalized Energy Analysis: Before vs. After Service

Key Findings

Thalo’s continuous cellular monitoring detected anomalous power draw on a Mitsubishi MXZ-SM36NAMHZ VRF heat pump. Field inspection confirmed a 40% refrigerant undercharge. After correction:

( R^{2} ) Daily kWh normalized by heating degree-days (base 65°F). Before/after compared via OLS regression with R² goodness-of-fit.

This fault would have gone undetected indefinitely without telemetry. Field surveys find 78% of installed systems have charge issues.

Fleet-Scale Impact (24,000 units)

Assuming 25% of units have charge faults at half this severity: ~7.2M kWh/yr wasted, ~$1.1M/yr excess electricity, and ~3,790 MT CO₂/yr of avoidable emissions.

Why This Matters

Colorado’s RMPA grid (1,159 lbs CO₂/MWh) is 43% more carbon-intensive than the national average. Every kWh saved here carries outsized climate impact.

References

  1. Domanski, Henderson & Payne (2014). NIST TN 1848: Improper installation increases HVAC energy use ~30%. Refrigerant charge identified as leading fault.
  2. Kim & Braun (2012). Int. J. Refrigeration: 25% undercharge → 15% COP loss; 40% interpolates to 25–40% degradation. Our 30% finding sits mid-range.
  3. Hu & Yuill (2020). Applied Thermal Engineering: Heat pump COP reductions up to 34% from refrigerant faults within normal safety limits.
  4. Mowris et al. (2004) / EPA eGRID (2023). 78% field undercharge prevalence (Phoenix). RMPA subregion: 1,158.9 lbs CO₂/MWh (eGRID 2021 data).